The National Student Clearinghouse released its preliminary fall enrollment report in November, and while the numbers are no longer brand new, they remain worth closer attention. The report shows total postsecondary enrollment up two percent over last year, driven largely by a 2.4 percent increase in undergraduate enrollment. At first glance, the figures appear to offer a rare piece of good news for higher education. A closer look, however, suggests something more limited.

These figures are, of course, preliminary. They reflect what colleges and universities report at the beginning of the semester, not what ultimately persists. Whether the modest gains are sustainable remains an open question, and there is reason to doubt that they are.

Graduate enrollment, for example, rose by just 0.1 percent. That near-flatline is telling. Graduate students are among the most informed educational consumers, and their tepid response comes despite the most vigorous marketing of graduate programs in decades. Notably, master’s degree programs—the workhorse of graduate education—actually declined by 0.6 percent.

That pattern aligns with what recent international enrollment data also show. As I have written previously, the decline in new international graduate enrollment reflects a broader recalibration in graduate education rather than a temporary or politically driven disruption. The Clearinghouse figures fit squarely within that same trend.

Where enrollment growth did occur is instructive. Community college enrollment rose by four percent, and undergraduate certificate programs grew by 6.6 percent, continuing strong gains from last year. What we are seeing is a shift away from traditional undergraduate education toward practical skills training. At the same time, declines in traditional programs are partly disguised by increased enrollment among students over age 25.

The most eye-catching figures in the report concern computer and information science. After years of substantial growth, enrollments in these programs are now falling sharply. Undergraduate enrollment declined by 5.8 percent in two-year programs and by a striking 15 percent at the graduate level. These programs appear to be reaping the results of graduating too many students for the available jobs. Word is out that a computer science degree is no longer a secure path to employment. But the term “available jobs” requires some unpacking. Companies continue to hire a great many people with computer science credentials. A large portion of those people are non-Americans who can often be hired at a discount. So, American students have to compete with foreign nationals, and the pool of jobs available to domestic graduates continues to shrink.

The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) also likely has something to do with this shift. Entry-level programming positions are disappearing as AI moves into that territory. Over time, this could have deleterious consequences for the industry. Talented individuals who are unable to gain access to the first rung of the career ladder may leave the field altogether, and AI may not suffice for roles that require more experienced computing professionals.

Read in context, the Clearinghouse data offer less evidence of renewed confidence in higher education than of continued realignment. Enrollment gains are concentrated in community colleges, certificate programs, health fields, and trades, while traditional graduate programs—and once-booming computer science degrees—lose ground. 

The headline numbers may appear encouraging, but the underlying story is one of narrowing expectations about what higher education can reliably deliver.

Follow the National Association of Scholars on X.

Image by iQoncept on Adobe; Asset ID#: 162582876