In the dead of night on November 21, a group of students linked to Sarah Lawrence College’s (SLC) Divestment Coalition stormed Westlands, the school’s main administrative building, and announced their occupation through social media. This was no quiet protest. Hiding their identities behind masks, the group decorated the building with signs, barricaded doors, and blocked windows with plywood, effectively shutting down the school’s operations. Dozens of students living in the dormitory above were trapped and access to key school offices were blocked. Outside, an encampment took shape, turning the scene into a spectacle broadcast across social media for the world to witness.
#BREAKING: Early this morning, radical anti-Israel students took over the Westlands administrative building at Sarah Lawrence College. They have barricaded the entrances and have launched an encampment outside the building.
The rioters are threatening to stay there until the… pic.twitter.com/N0dUYyJPBs
— Israel War Room (@IsraelWarRoom) November 21, 2024
Over the course of the first chaotic day, the school’s administration failed to condemn the behavior or intervene to end the occupation of the building. By remaining silent and inactive in response to such a highly visible breach of rules, the school effectively took a political stance against Zionism. This inaction stands in direct contradiction to its March declaration to “ provide an environment in which all of our students — regardless of background, belief, or circumstance — have the unimpeded opportunity to actively and fully participate in the educational experience that is at the center of Sarah Lawrence’s mission” (original emphasis).
View this post on Instagram
To date, no public statement condemning the actions of the Divestment group has been made by SLC’s President, Cristle C. Judd.
Only in an email to SLC community members did she say that the situation merely required the “relocat[ion] [of] some classes and administrative functions out of Westlands and temporarily suspend shuttle service.” She further stated that school’s “top priority is the safety and well-being of all on campus,” and noted that the “Dean of Students Dave Stanfield and his staff have communicated with students who reside in Westlands to offer support and resources and to open a line of communication should these students have any needs throughout the day.” But even if arrangements for students residing in the building were made, the group’s barricading of the building should be seen as an act of intimidation by the protesters—no student should have to navigate such a demonstration just to access their residence.
[RELATED: Sarah Lawrence Leaders Make Hollow Commitments to Free Expression]
In the same email, the president demonstrated yet another act of complicity—or, at best, naivety—towards the protesters, stating:
The College has not summoned outside law enforcement. Having been informed of their safety violations, we trust that today’s participants and their events will proceed in a manner consistent with clearly communicated college policies. We are confident we will navigate this moment together as a community.
The following day, while the building occupation had ended, the encampment outside only expanded, making President Judd’s email to the campus community on November 22 all the more difficult to reconcile with reality. She wrote, “Today, campus operations are back to normal.” They were not—the encampment remained firmly in place.
Adding to this surreal scenario, the Dean of Students issued a statement on November 23 that ostensibly framed the rules for guests as stricter but, in effect, welcomed outside agitators and radical participants as “guests.” These individuals were permitted on campus from dawn to dusk, purportedly to maintain the “health and safety of our community.” Here is how the Dean phrased it:
The safety of all members of our campus community remains our top priority and chief concern. Given your repeated calls inviting numerous individuals not affiliated with the College to campus, whose identity and intentions are not known, and following consultation with members of the senior team, effective immediately guests you have invited to participate will only be permitted on campus from dawn-to-dusk in order to maintain the health and safety of our community.
Struggle Video News released a short documentary on YouTube, which was filmed on Day 3 of the protest, according to its creator. The footage showcases the encampment and includes a statement from one of the coalition’s members, who goes by the name Armand:
When President Judd says, “I want to be clear that peaceful protest has long been a part of Sarah Lawrence’s history. I want to be equally clear that some of yesterday’s actions crossed lines in ways that cannot be ignored or condoned. Students whose actions threatened the health and safety of those in our community or who knowingly and repeatedly violated clearly communicated college policies will be subject to disciplinary action through the student conduct hearing process,” such words ring hollow to me.
For decades, SLC has permitted anti-Semitic and illiberal behavior to go unchecked. Judd herself sanctioned this same group’s disruption of last spring’s commencement address and has now effectively validated their views in this latest episode. The messages broadcast to Jewish students and the broader world were the antithesis of mutual respect and understanding.
As Senator Tom Cotton aptly remarked to protesters wearing the Palestinian keffiyeh in a Senate office building this week, “It’s a terrorist symbol and you should be ashamed for wearing it.”
A must-watch masterclass from Senator Tom Cotton.
“It’s a terrorist symbol and you should be ashamed for wearing it.” pic.twitter.com/gtOqRsWX6m
— Eyal Yakoby (@EYakoby) November 23, 2024
Similarly, these students at SLC hid their identities in Westlands and issued demands not for dialogue but for destruction. They called for harm against Zionists, the eradication of Israel, and displayed deeply inflammatory slogans such as “Long live the intifada!”
This fall, as I held open houses for my courses on polarization and the American presidency, the Divestment Coalition disrupted them by calling for a boycott and spreading libel. Their campaign failed, and my classes were filled with brave, committed students. The cause of this protest was my belief that Israel has the right to exist and defend itself, especially in the wake of the October 7 Hamas attacks. While I understand that students sometimes protest out of ignorance, neither faculty nor the administration acted against this disruption, which violated campus rules and stifled free expression. I publicly urged President Judd to stand for free speech and condemn the intimidation of students afraid to enroll in my classes. She did not respond and remained silent.
[RELATED: Sarah Lawrence College’s Answer to Anti-Semitism? Submit a Form and Move On]
For years, the administration has not promoted genuine liberal thinking, instead allowing groups like the Divestment Coalition to grow unchecked. This has taught students nothing about free speech, civility, or how to bring about change. Now, at the end of the semester, after being denied their divestment demand, these students have occupied the school’s main building and set up an encampment, refusing to explain or justify their views to even liberal outlets like the New York Times and the College has no clear plan to address any of this.
View this post on Instagram
SLC has failed in its core mission of being an educational institution. Congressman Richie Torres is absolutely right in stating that these students are “Juvenile delinquents, casting themselves in the role of martyrs or jihadists, are theatrically occupying—or in their words ‘liberating’—Westlands in Sarah Lawrence College. These so-called ‘liberators’ are not activists but actors, more interested in performing than in problem-solving.”
Juvenile delinquents, casting themselves in the role of martyrs or jihadists, are theatrically occupying—or in their words “liberating”—Westlands in Sarah Lawrence College.
These so-called “liberators” are not activists but actors, more interested in performing than in… pic.twitter.com/I38WjaJlWC
— Ritchie Torres (@RitchieTorres) November 22, 2024
The students’ behavior is performative; it is causing harm to their peers as well as to the school’s mission and core functions. The college should ask law enforcement to end this charade, and these students should be held fully accountable and must face consequences, including expulsion. Judd should be removed from office, and the school needs to return to its true values of actually providing a liberal education so that its students can “tackle the problems of, and thrive in, a complex and rapidly evolving world.” Sarah Lawrence College has fallen; it can be rebuilt with the right guidance and leadership. None of this should have happened, and it is a direct result of educational malpractice and disastrous leadership by the school’s president.
Image of Sarah Lawrence College Has Fallen by TargetMarget on Wikimedia Commons
“How is that not kidnapping???”
Because that literally never happened. I go there and the coverage of this is insanely skewed. There’s literally footage of CAMPUS SAFETY refusing to let students into their dorms that lived in Westlands, while the SJP let students in! The “barricade” were some wooden planks placed in front and kept administration out and students and faculty could do whatever. NO ONE WAS TRAPPED IN THE BUILDING.
Wooden planks that keep the “administration” out but let “students and faculty” pass?
What kind of wood is this? And let *all* the professors pass? Including Professor Abrams?
And I hate to tell you, but all you need is one student who remained in the dorm out of fear and they (you?) are guilty of kidnapping. Look at it this way — you don’t have to fire a gun in a bank robbery for it to be considered armed, there is the implicit threat that you could.
And folks are damn lucky that *I* am not an administrator at that college because I would have borrowed a chain saw from the grounds crew and those magical planks would quickly have become magical kindling..,.
Ummm…yes, they were.
These students are reprehensible and, as remarked, performative.
But equally as egregious is Cotton’s claim that the Palestinian keffiyeh — representing only a legitimate desire to be free from Israeli occupation and have self-determination — is a terrorist symbol.
And a swastika is also an innocent Native American symbol — prior to Hitler, the Boy Scout’s Order of the Arrow award was the Order of the White Swastika. The word swastika comes from Sanskrit where it means “conducive to well-being.” Swastikas are an important (positive) symbol in both the Buddhist and Hindu religions. Et cetera.
Yet if you show up wearing a swastika, people will presume that you are a Neo Nazi.
I think that Senator Cotton did a good job of explaining how Yasser Arafa made the keffiyeh represent terrorism, much like Hitler made the swastika represent National Socialism. I also think that Senator Cotton should be commended for his professionalism in dealing with that troublemaker — I would have pointed out that there aren’t pink keffiyehs because radical Islam requires women to wear Burkas, and that neither she nor Code Pink would last ten seconds in a place like Iran.
“But equally as egregious is Cotton’s claim”
I don’t care if Senator Cotton claimed that the Moon was made out of Blue Cheese and he wanted to see pieces of it included in the School Lunch Program. That’s mere speech, said by someone who didn’t start the conversation and clearly didn’t want to be involved in it.
To say that is as egregious as actual crimes is asinine. Regardless of your motive or beliefs, Breaking & Entering, Kidnapping, Trespass, Assault and such are criminal offenses.
And while we are talking about crimes, why wasn’t this woman arrested and prosecuted for Trespassing in the Capitol or whatever the Jan 6th folk are being charged with?!?
You are setting a great example for other professors and administrators to speak out about the injustices to students, employees, on other campuses who enable terrorist sympathizers and antisemites to take over campuses–physically and psychologically by shouting down and extending violence for those who do not agree with them.
” Dozens of students living in the dormitory above were trapped”
How is that not “kidnapping”?!?
While the NY authorities may not prosecute this, the Trump Justice Department very well might and 18 USC 1201 has a minimum sentence of 20 years. The statute includes “confines” and “uses the mail or any means, facility, or instrumentality of interstate or foreign commerce in committing or in furtherance of the commission of the offense.”
Instagram is in California, and notwithstanding that, there is longstanding Federal precedent that anything on the internet travels interstate because of how the internet works, with packets inevitably crossing state lines. So these little darlings used “Interstate Commerce” to organize/publicize this, and that creates the Federal nexis for prosecution.
Even if Trump’s USA can’t get a conviction, it very much will be a wakeup call for these little darlings — and one Federal prosecution like this would end a lot of this foolishness.
“How is that not kidnapping???”
Because that literally never happened. I go there and the coverage of this is insanely skewed. There’s literally footage of CAMPUS SAFETY refusing to let students into their dorms that lived in Westlands, while the SJP let students in! The “barricade” were some wooden planks placed in front and kept administration out and students and faculty could do whatever. NO ONE WAS TRAPPED IN THE BUILDING.